Cross-Border Estate Planning Guide · Volume 5 of 6. Option E: Trust in India and US. A modular playbook, built on one real family’s estate across India and the United States.
The Series
Every volume in this series structures the same estate – Mr. Arjun’s Indian and Washington-State assets under a different succession vehicle. This volume covers Option E.
| Option | Structure | Volume |
|---|---|---|
| A | Will only | 1 |
| B | Will in India + gift of US estate | 2 |
| C | Will in India + QDOT in US | 3 |
| D | Trust in India + QDOT in US | 4 |
| E | Trust in India and US | 5—this volume |
| F | Foreign grantor trust | 6 |
The Family & The Succession
A two-generation family holding assets in India and the United States. The fact pattern Option E is tested against.
Mr. Arjun
Father · First generation: Status: Indian citizen, Indian tax resident, Indian domicile. Not a US citizen.
Role in succession: Primary settlor; actual owner of Indian and US assets.
Mumbai, Maharashtra
Demise · July 2026
Mrs. Arjun
Mother · First generation: Status: Indian citizen, Indian tax resident, Indian domicile. Not a US citizen.
Role in succession: Surviving spouse.
Mumbai, Maharashtra
Demise · August 2028
Mr. Rohan
Son · Second generation: Status: US citizen (naturalised); US tax resident.
Role in succession: Successor trustee; ultimate beneficiary of the entire estate after Mrs. Arjun.
Seattle, Washington
Demise · NA
Mrs. Rohan
Daughter-in-law · Second generation: Status: US citizen (naturalised); US tax resident.
Role in succession: Receives the AM Technologies shares held by Mrs. Arjun on her demise.
Seattle, Washington
Demise · NA
The Estate Register – India | Acquisition
Seven Indian assets held across Mr. and Mrs. Arjun. Original cost is converted at the exchange rate of the year of purchase.
| Asset | State | Ownership Mr. Arjun : Mrs. Arjun | Purchase year | Original cost (INR) | Original cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mumbai residential flat 3BHK, ~1,800 sqft, prime suburb (Bandra/Powai area) | India - Maharashtra | 100 : 0 | 2003 | INR 80,00,000 | USD 171,748 |
| Chennai villa 4BHK, ~3,500 sqft plot, ECR / Adyar area | India - Tamil Nadu | 100 : 0 | 2012 | INR 1,20,00,000 | USD 224,551 |
| AM Technologies Pvt. Ltd. IT services company | India - Maharashtra | 60 : 40 | 2005 | INR 10,00,000 | USD 22,676 |
| Indian listed equities Diversified portfolio | India | 70 : 30 | 2020 | INR 4,00,00,000 | USD 523,697 |
| Indian equity mutual funds Separate individual investments | India | 100 : 0 | 2019 | INR 4,50,00,000 | USD 639,295 |
| Bank FDs & savings accounts 10 year, joint (interest @ 7%) | India | 50 : 50 | 2020 | INR 50,00,000 | USD 65,462 |
| Agricultural land Nashik, Maharashtra (rural) | India - Maharashtra | 100 : 0 | 2008 | INR 50,00,000 | USD 114,916 |
| Total Indian Estate (A) | INR 11,60,00,000 | USD 1,762,345 |
The Estate Register – USA | Acquisition
Two US assets, both held by Mr. Arjun. The USD/INR rates below drive every conversion in this volume.
| Asset | State | Ownership Mr. : Mrs. Arjun | Purchase year | Original cost (INR) | Original cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Washington residential property Washington State | USA - Washington State | 100 : 0 | 2005 | INR 3,20,000 | USD 7,256 |
| US listed shares USA | USA | 100 : 0 | 2018 | INR 2,80,000 | USD 3,995 |
| Total USA Estate (B) | INR 6,00,000 | USD 11,251 | |||
| Total Estate (C = A + B) | INR 11,66,00,000 | USD 1,773,596 |
Exchange rates · USD / INR
| Year | USD / INR |
|---|---|
| 2003 | 46.58 |
| 2005 | 44.10 |
| 2008 | 43.51 |
| 2012 | 53.44 |
| 2018 | 70.09 |
| 2019 | 70.39 |
| 2020 | 76.38 |
| 2026 | 95.00 |
| 2028 | 105.00 |
| 2032 | 125.00 |
Rates are at the year of purchase or the valuation date (2026, 2028 and 2032).
The Estate Register – India | Value at Each Date
Indian estate at the demise of Mr. Arjun (2026), at the demise of Mrs. Arjun (2028, also the year of sale) and in 2032. Ownership and purchase details are on the acquisition page.
| Asset | 2026 INR | 2026 USD | 2028 INR | 2028 USD | 2032 INR | 2032 USD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mumbai residential flat | INR 7,50,00,000 | USD 789,474 | INR 8,68,21,800 | USD 826,874 | INR 16,50,00,000 | USD 1,320,000 |
| Chennai villa | INR 4,20,00,000 | USD 442,105 | INR 4,72,44,200 | USD 449,945 | INR 8,56,00,000 | USD 684,800 |
| AM Technologies Pvt. Ltd. | INR 18,00,00,000 | USD 1,894,737 | INR 25,28,87,000 | USD 2,408,448 | INR 26,00,00,000 | USD 2,080,000 |
| Indian listed equities | INR 5,20,00,000 | USD 547,368 | INR 8,54,37,000 | USD 813,686 | INR 12,00,00,000 | USD 960,000 |
| Indian equity mutual funds | INR 5,80,00,000 | USD 610,526 | INR 8,82,10,700 | USD 840,102 | INR 10,80,00,000 | USD 864,000 |
| Bank FDs & savings accounts | INR 3,50,00,000 | USD 368,421 | INR 4,10,98,400 | USD 391,413 | INR 5,05,00,000 | USD 404,000 |
| Agricultural land | INR 2,80,00,000 | USD 294,737 | INR 3,33,48,400 | USD 317,604 | INR 6,60,00,000 | USD 528,000 |
| Total Indian Estate (A) | INR 47,00,00,000 | USD 4,947,368 | INR 63,50,47,500 | USD 6,048,071 | INR 85,51,00,000 | USD 6,840,800 |
The Estate Register – USA | Value at Each Date
US estate on the same three dates, followed by the total estate.
| Asset | 2026 INR | 2026 USD | 2028 INR | 2028 USD | 2032 INR | 2032 USD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Washington residential property | INR 9,02,50,000 | USD 950,000 | INR 17,23,68,000 | USD 1,641,600 | INR 33,59,37,500 | USD 2,687,500 |
| US listed shares | INR 4,56,00,000 | USD 480,000 | INR 7,46,69,818 | USD 711,141 | INR 12,00,00,000 | USD 960,000 |
| Total USA Estate (B) | INR 13,58,50,000 | USD 1,430,000 | INR 24,70,37,818 | USD 2,352,741 | INR 45,59,37,500 | USD 3,647,500 |
Total estate (C = A + B)
| Year | INR | USD |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | INR 60,58,50,000 | USD 6,377,368 |
| 2028 | INR 88,20,85,318 | USD 8,400,813 |
| 2032 | INR 1,31,10,37,500 | USD 10,488,300 |
Executive Summary
Present-value tax cost of Option E in the US and India, and the amount Mr. Rohan can repatriate.
| Measure | Amount | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Present value of US tax cost | USD 383,686 | Gift tax and US tax on sale; PV 2026 |
| Present value of India tax cost | INR 2,69,44,174 | Tax on the 2028 sale; PV 2026 |
| Available for repatriation | USD 2,976,298 | After Indian tax |
| Repatriation timeline | 2.98 years | At USD 1 million per financial year |
The assumed discounting rate is 8%. Stamp duty on trust settlement in India of INR 70,20,000 is not included in the present value of India tax cost.
Pros
- If the trust is a genuine irrevocable gift, the US-situs assets sit outside both gross estates.
- Probate is eliminated in both India and the US.
- Mrs. Arjun is protected as life beneficiary under the Indian private trust.
- A single irrevocable US trust is simpler to run than a QDOT: no US-trustee security requirements or Form 706-QDT filings.
Cons
- Mr. Arjun must irrevocably part with the US assets in 2026; any retained string brings back §2036/2038 estate inclusion.
- Upfront Indian stamp duty and registration on settling Indian immovable property into the trust.
- Dual-jurisdiction trust set-up and ongoing administration costs.
How Option E Works (1 of 2)
The two trusts, from their settlement to the demise of Mr. Arjun in 2026.
The Indian trust
Indian trust settled
Mr. Arjun settles an Indian private trust over the Indian estate, with Mrs. Arjun as life beneficiary and Mr. Rohan as ultimate beneficiary. Succession over the Indian assets passes under the trust deed, with no probate.
2026 · Lifetime gift
US irrevocable trust settled
Mr. Arjun transfers the Washington property and US shares to a US irrevocable trust as a completed gift. An independent US trustee (a US citizen or domestic corporate trustee) holds all distribution and administrative powers, and Mr. Arjun retains no right to revoke, amend or benefit from the trust.
The transfer of the Washington property into the trust is exempt from Washington REET.
2026 · Demise of Mr. Arjun
Outside his US estate
The assets are then held in trust for Mrs. Arjun.
As a completed gift with no retained powers, the US assets are excluded from Mr. Arjun's NRA gross estate under IRC §2101 and §2103; §2036(a)(2) and §2038 are not triggered. The US trust also avoids US probate on the Washington property.
How Option E Works (2 of 2)
The second demise, the Indian estate passing to Mr. Rohan under the trust, and the sale and repatriation.
2028 · Demise of Mrs. Arjun
Mrs. Arjun passes
On Mrs. Arjun's demise in 2028:
The AM Technologies shares held by Mrs. Arjun are transmitted to Mrs. Rohan.
The Indian assets pass to Mr. Rohan under the trust. He may hold them under Section 6(5) of FEMA, and on sale the proceeds are credited to Mr. Rohan's NRO account on distribution by the trust.
Sale
Mr. Rohan sells
The inherited properties, shares, mutual funds and other investments may be sold to persons resident or non-resident in India.
Agricultural land, plantation property and farmhouses may be transferred only to persons resident in India.
Repatriation
Proceeds repatriated
Repatriation of up to USD 1 million per financial year from the NRO account; any excess requires prior RBI approval.
US Federal Gift Tax – Implications
A completed gift to the US trust in 2026: the Washington property is taxed, the US shares are not.
Washington property: a taxable gift
Mr. Arjun's irrevocable, completed transfer of the Washington property to the US trust is a taxable gift of US-situs real property by a non-resident alien (NRA) under § 2501(a)(1).
No annual exclusion applies, since a gift in trust with no present interest carved out does not qualify under § 2503(b).
US listed shares: outside the gift tax
The transfer of the US listed shares is a gift of intangible property by an NRA and is excluded from US gift tax entirely under § 2501(a)(2).
Indicative US federal gift tax: USD 326,300, payable on the Washington property in 2026.
US Federal Gift Tax – Computation
Paid by Mr. Arjun in 2026 on the Washington property gifted to the US trust. The US listed shares are not taxed.
| Particulars | Gift in 2026 |
|---|---|
| Washington residential property | USD 950,000 |
| US listed shares (intangible – § 2501(a)(2)) | NA |
| Less: annual exclusion (gift in trust) | USD 0 |
| Total taxable gift | USD 950,000 |
| Tax amount on gift | USD 326,300 |
| Taxes at present value – 2026 | USD 326,300 |
How the tax is computed: USD 248,300 on the first USD 750,000 of the taxable gift, plus 39% on the balance of USD 200,000. No discounting applies, as the gift tax is paid in 2026.
Taxable gift: USD 950,000
Washington property · 2026
Us federal gift tax: USD 326,300
Payable in 2026 · PV 2026
Annual exclusion: USD 0
Gift in trust · § 2503(b)
Indian Income Tax – Implications
The Indian trust is taxed when the Indian assets are sold in 2028. The rates below apply to a private discretionary trust under the Income-tax Act, 2025.
Long-term capital gains of the trust
Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, long-term capital gains (LTCG) of a private discretionary trust are taxable at the concessional rate of 12.5% under Sections 197 and 198, together with the applicable surcharge and 4% Health and Education Cess. This position is supported by the Mumbai Tribunal decisions in Jitendra Gala Navneet Trust and Anil Gala Navneet Trust, read with Section 164, CBDT Circular No. 6-P dated 6 July 1968, and CWT v. Trustees of H.E.H. Nizam's Family Trust (108 ITR 555) (SC).
Bank interest and other income
Other income, such as bank interest, is taxable at the Maximum Marginal Rate (MMR) of 30%, together with the applicable surcharge under the Finance Act and 4% Health and Education Cess. Niti Trust & Ors. v. CIT (221 ITR 435) (Guj) supports applying the MMR to discretionary trusts, while the Special Bench decision in Araadhya Jain Trust v. ITO (212 ITD 1) is confined to determining the applicable surcharge on MMR-taxed income.
For this illustration, the trust is assumed to be a private irrevocable discretionary trust. The tax implications would differ if the trust were characterised as a specific trust or a revocable trust under section 97 of the Income-tax Act, 2025.
Capital Gains Tax – India
Sale in the year 2028. Gains are taxed at the rates applicable to the trust: 14.95% on long-term capital gains and 39% on bank interest. Rural agricultural land is not a capital asset.
Sale consideration · 2028: INR 34,39,38,988
India tax on the sale: INR 3,14,27,684
India tax · present value 2026: INR 2,69,44,174
| Particulars | Mumbai Flat | Chennai Villa | India Listed Shares | India Mutual funds | Bank FD | Agricultural land | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sale consideration | INR 8,68,21,800 | INR 4,72,44,200 | INR 8,54,37,000 | INR 8,82,10,700 | INR 28,76,888 | INR 3,33,48,400 | INR 34,39,38,988 |
| Less: cost of acquisition | (INR 80,00,000) | (INR 1,20,00,000) | (INR 4,00,00,000) | (INR 4,50,00,000) | – | (INR 50,00,000) | (INR 11,00,00,000) |
| Long term capital gain | INR 7,88,21,800 | INR 3,52,44,200 | INR 4,54,37,000 | INR 4,32,10,700 | INR 28,76,888 | INR 2,83,48,400 | INR 23,39,38,988 |
| India tax rate | 14.95% | 14.95% | 14.95% | 14.95% | 39% | Nil | – |
| India tax amount | INR 1,17,83,859 | INR 52,69,008 | INR 67,92,832 | INR 64,60,000 | INR 11,21,986 | – | INR 3,14,27,684 |
| Taxes at present value – 2026 | INR 1,01,02,760 | INR 45,17,325 | INR 58,23,758 | INR 55,38,408 | INR 9,61,922 | – | INR 2,69,44,174 |
US Income Tax – Implications
How Mr. Rohan is taxed in the US when the Indian assets are sold in 2028.
Capital gains on carryover cost
As Mr. Arjun's transfer is a completed irrevocable gift, no § 1014 step-up is available. Capital gains on the US-situs and Indian assets are computed on carryover (original) cost under § 1015.
The maximum effective rate is 23.8%: 20% long-term capital gains tax under § 1(h) plus 3.8% net investment income tax (NIIT) under § 1411.
Bank interest
Interest income from bank deposits is taxable in Mr. Rohan's hands in the US. The 15% rate under the India–USA DTAA caps India's tax on the interest, not the US tax.
For this illustration, the US tax on the interest is computed at 15% and is fully covered by the credit for Indian tax.
Taxes paid in India can be claimed as a credit in the US. Washington's 7% capital gains excise tax applies separately on share and mutual fund gains above the annual deduction, with no foreign tax credit against it.
Capital Gains Tax – United States
Sale in the year 2028, taxed in Mr. Rohan's hands on carryover cost, with a credit for the Indian tax. For this illustration, the capital gains and tax rates are as per 2026 rates.
Us federal tax before credit: USD 330,483
Us federal tax after credit · 2028: USD 51,479
Us tax · present value 2026: USD 44,135
| Particulars | Mumbai Flat | Chennai Villa | India Listed Shares | India Mutual funds | Bank FD | Agricultural land | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sale consideration | USD 826,874 | USD 449,945 | USD 813,686 | USD 840,102 | USD 27,399 | USD 317,604 | USD 3,275,609 |
| Less: cost of acquisition | (USD 171,748) | (USD 224,551) | (USD 523,697) | (USD 639,295) | – | (USD 114,916) | (USD 1,674,207) |
| Long term gain / income | USD 655,127 | USD 225,394 | USD 289,988 | USD 200,807 | USD 27,399 | USD 202,688 | USD 1,601,402 |
| US tax rate | 23.8% | 23.8% | 23.8% | 23.8% | 15% | Nil | – |
| US tax amount | USD 155,920 | USD 53,644 | USD 69,017 | USD 47,792 | USD 4,110 | – | USD 330,483 |
| Less: foreign tax credit | (USD 112,227) | (USD 50,181) | (USD 64,694) | (USD 47,792) | (USD 4,110) | – | (USD 279,004) |
| US tax after credit · 2028 | USD 43,693 | USD 3,463 | USD 4,324 | – | – | – | USD 51,479 |
| Taxes at present value – 2026 | USD 37,460 | USD 2,969 | USD 3,707 | – | – | – | USD 44,135 |
Washington Capital Gains Excise Tax
Sale in the year 2028. Washington's 7% excise applies to long-term gains on shares and mutual funds above the annual deduction, with no foreign tax credit against it.
| Particulars | Sale in 2028 |
|---|---|
| India listed shares – long-term gain | USD 289,988 |
| India mutual funds – long-term gain | USD 200,807 |
| Total income | USD 490,795 |
| Less: annual deduction | (USD 270,000) |
| Taxable income | USD 220,795 |
| Tax on the above (7%) | USD 15,456 |
| Taxes at present value – 2026 | USD 13,251 |
Not applicable: Mumbai flat, Chennai villa, Bank FD and agricultural land.
Washington capital gains excise: USD 15,456
On share and fund gains · 2028
Present value · 2026: USD 13,251
Discounted at 8% for 2 years
Annual deduction: USD 270,000
Deducted before the 7% rate
Time for Repatriation
From 2028. Net Indian proceeds, after Indian tax, are remitted from Mr. Rohan’s NRO account within the FEMA ceiling.
Total repatriable amount: USD 2,976,298
Fema limit per financial year: USD 1M
To repatriate back to the usa: 2.98 years
| Particulars | Mumbai Flat | Chennai Villa | India Listed Shares | India Mutual funds | Bank FD | Agricultural land | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amount available for repatriation in INR | INR 7,50,37,941 | INR 4,19,75,192 | INR 7,86,44,168 | INR 8,17,50,700 | INR 17,54,902 | INR 3,33,48,400 | INR 31,25,11,304 |
| Amount available for repatriation in USD | USD 714,647 | USD 399,764 | USD 748,992 | USD 778,578 | USD 16,713 | USD 317,604 | USD 2,976,298 |
FEMA repatriation limit: allowed up to USD 1M per financial year.
FEMA Implications (1 of 2)
Mr. Rohan, an NRI, as beneficiary of the Indian trust, and the sale proceeds distributed to him.
Mr. Rohan as ultimate beneficiary
The Indian trust deed governs devolution of the Indian estate. Mr. Rohan, as an NRI/OCI, can be a beneficiary of an Indian private trust holding immovable property, and may continue to hold such trust interests under Section 6(5) of FEMA, 1999. However, if Mr. Rohan does not hold OCI registration, RBI approval would be required for holding or selling immovable property through the trust.
Distribution of sale proceeds
On distribution by the trust, sale proceeds from the trust assets will be credited to Mr. Rohan's NRO account. Agricultural land can only be transferred to a resident citizen of India; any violation attracts a penalty of three times the property value under Section 13(1) of FEMA, 1999.
FEMA Implications (2 of 2)
Remittance of the sale proceeds outside India.
Repatriation limit
Repatriation of sale proceeds is governed by Regulation 4(2) of the FEMA (Remittance of Assets) Regulations, 2016 (Notification No. FEMA 13(R)/2016-RB). Repatriation is permitted up to USD 1 million per financial year from the NRO account.
Above USD 1 million
Repatriation in excess of USD 1 million per financial year requires prior approval from the RBI.
Repatriation from the NRO account is allowed up to USD 1M per financial year.
Stamp Duty – Trust Settlement (India)
Settling the Indian immovable property into the trust attracts stamp duty upfront.
Stamp duty on trust settlement
Stamp duty on trust settlement at 6% is applicable.
INR 70,20,000
Stamp duty on trust settlement (India) at 6%.
Not applicable in Option E: Will registration · Probate in India and the USA · Stamp duty in the USA · US federal estate tax · Indian estate tax
Other Charges
Costs beyond tax and stamp duty in India and in Washington.
India
Valuation and appraisal charges, certified copy charges, municipal mutation charges, share and mutual fund transmission charges, and power of attorney agent fees, where appointed.
United States (Washington)
County Auditor deed recording fees and REET affidavit filing charges, attorney's fees (approximately USD 200–400 per hour), property appraisal charges (approximately USD 300–600) and certified copy charges.
Solique Advisors · India | UAE | USA | Canada.

