Domestic Tax Pulse Updates & Key Rulings Q1 of FY 2025-26

India’s direct and indirect tax developments for Q1 of FY 2025-26, including notifications, compliance updates and key rulings.

By Chirag Baid18 min readnewsletter

PDF · 13 pages · 2.2 MB

Original PDF cover for Domestic Tax Pulse Updates & Key Rulings Q1 of FY 2025-26
The original Solique Advisors publication
In this publication

Note From CEO

Dear Readers,

As we open Q1 of FY 2025–26, I am delighted to bring you this combined update that captures the depth, rigor, and global relevance of our team’s work across both domestic and international tax landscapes.

On the domestic front, the compliance environment continues to evolve with expanded safe-harbor thresholds, new sector-specific rules such as those for cruise operators, and sharper judicial clarity on ESOP treatment, commission disallowances, and tax treaty interpretations each of these shaping how businesses plan and report.

On the international stage, developments such as the United States stepping away from OECD Pillar talks, enhanced CBC reporting, European transfer pricing reforms, and key treaty rulings remind us that tax strategy now demands both global awareness and local agility.

Whether you are navigating regulatory changes or exploring new planning opportunities, our curated insights are designed to support your decision-making and strengthen your strategic direction. At Solique Advisors, we remain committed to equipping you with insight-driven tools, robust research, and a sharp analytical edge that empowers confident action in a fast-shifting tax environment.

With regards,

Chirag Baid Co-Founder & CEO Solique Group

Direct Tax Updates

April 2025

April 03, 2025 Notification No. 3/2025 and Notification No. 6/2025 Mandatory Aadhaar Intimation for PAN Holders:

  • CBDT has inserted sub-rule (5AA) under Rule 114 of Income tax Rules,1962 (‘IT Rules).
  • Individuals allotted PAN on the basis of an Aadhaar Enrolment ID (application filed before October 1, 2024) must now intimate their Aadhaar number to the Principal Director General of Income-tax (Systems) or authorised authority on or before December 31, 2025.

April 07, 2025 Notification No. 30 / 2025 New Rule 12AE Introduced for ITR Filing Post Search/Requisition (ITR-B Form)

  • CBDT has inserted Rule 12AE, effective retrospectively from September 1, 2024.

  • Applicable to person subject to search or requisition proceedings under Sections 132 or 132A initiated on or after September 1, 2024.

  • Mandates filing of Form ITR-B for such cases under Section 158BC(1)(a).

  • Framework enables standardized processing of returns in block assessment cases involving undisclosed income.

Authentication for ITR-B:

  • Companies, political parties, and those liable to tax audit (Section 44AB) must file using digital signature.
  • Other taxpayers may file using electronic verification code (EVC).

April 07, 2025 Notification No. 31 / 2025 HUDCO Bonds notified as Long-Term Specified Asset u/s 54EC:

  • CBDT has notified that bonds issued by Housing and Urban Development Corporation Limited (HUDCO) on or after April 1, 2025, redeemable after 5 years, will qualify as ‘long- term specified assets’ under Section 54EC of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (‘IT Act’).
  • Investment in such bonds allows for capital gains exemption, subject to conditions prescribed.
  • Investments in HUDCO bonds can range from INR 20,000 to INR 50 lakh in a financial year, come with a 5-year lock-in period, and offer a fixed annual return of 5.25%; the interest earned is taxable.

April 22, 2025 Notification No. 35 & 36 / 2025 CBDT notifies TCS on Sale of Luxury and Collectible Goods; Amendments to Form 27EQ:

CBDT has inserted sub-rule (5AA) under Rule 114 of IT Rules.

  • CBDT has expanded the scope of Tax Collected at Source (TCS) to include the sale of the following luxury and collectible goods exceeding value of INR 10 lakhs:

  • Yachts, rowing boats, canoes, helicopters

  • Antiques, paintings, sculptures

  • Wrist watches

  • Sunglasses, handbags, purses

  • Branded footwear and sports kits (including golf kits and ski-wear)

  • Home theatre systems

  • Horses used for racing and polo

  • Collectibles such as coins and stamps

  • Form 27EQ has been amended accordingly to include these items for reporting of TCS collected on their sale.

April 23, 2025 Notification No. 38 / 2025 CBDT Notified Disallowance of Settlement Expenditure under the IT Act for various laws

  • CBDT has specified certain laws under which any expenditure incurred for settlement of proceedings related to contraventions shall be disallowed for tax purposes under the Act.

  • The disallowance applies to settlements made in respect of proceedings initiated under the following laws:

  • Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) Act, 1992.

  • Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act (SCRA), 1956.

  • Depositories Act, 1996.

  • Competition Act, 2002.

  • This means that if a taxpayer incurs any expenditure to settle proceedings under these laws, such expenses cannot be claimed as deductions while computing income under the Act.

May 2025

CBDT Notifies Income Tax Return (ITR) Forms for AY 2025–26

ITR FormNotification No.Date
ITR-1 (Sahaj)40/2025April 29, 2025
ITR-4 (Sugam)40/2025April 29, 2025
ITR-341/2025April 30, 2025
ITR-542/2025May 1, 2025
ITR-243/2025May 3, 2025
ITR-644/2025May 6, 2025
ITR-V (Verification Form)45/2025May 9, 2025
ITR-746/2025May 9, 2025
ITR-U (Updated Return)49/2025May 19, 2025

Indirect Tax Updates

April 2025

April 17,2025 Instruction No. 03/2025-GST CBIC instruction on 17.04.2025 – Guidelines for processing of GST registration applications

  • Instructs proper officers to strictly follow the document list prescribed in FORM GST REG-01 and not to seek additional documents unless officially sanctioned.
  • Clarifies verification procedures for ownership/possession of the principal place of business guidance provided for different scenarios.
  • Only essential proof of business constitution to be requested; unnecessary or repetitive documentation must be avoided.
  • Registration applications to be processed within 7 working days for non-risky applicants and within 30 days for flagged/risky applicants, including mandatory physical verification.
  • Officers directed to avoid presumptive objections; all queries must be specific, relevant, and recorded with reasoning.

April 24, 2025 Notification No. G.S.R 256E Procedural framework notified for GSTAT operations

  • Mandatory e-filing of appeals through the designated GSTAT portal.
  • Specifies clear documentation requirements, including certified copies of the appealed orders.
  • Defines the powers of the Tribunal, including the ability to extend timelines and summon additional records as necessary.
  • Permits both virtual and physical hearings, offering procedural flexibility.
  • Notifies fee structure for filing interlocutory applications, obtaining certified copies, and other services.
  • Warns of cost consequences in case of procedural non-compliance by the parties.

May 2025

May 10, 2025 Notification No. 12/2025-Customs (ADD)

CBIC imposes anti-dumping duty on imports of Titanium Dioxide (TiO₂) from China PR, under tariff items 2823 00 10, 3206 11 10, and 3206 11 90.

The duty follows final findings of the DGTR, which concluded:

(i) Dumping of Titanium Dioxide at unfair prices from China PR.

(ii) Material injury to domestic industry.

(iii) Injury directly caused by dumped imports.

May 10, 2025 Notification No. 12/2025-Customs (ADD)

  • Duty imposed on both direct and indirect exports (via third countries) of TiO₂ from China PR by specified producers/traders.
  • Amount of duty: Ranges from USD 460 to USD 681 per metric tonne, depending on the exporter/producer.
  • The duty shall remain in force for five years from the date of publication in the Official Gazette, unless revoked or amended earlier.
  • Certain product types are excluded (e.g. food- grade, pharma-grade, cosmetic/sunscreen, and some textile/fibre applications).
  • For calculating the duty, applicable rate will be as notified under Section 14 of the Customs Act, 1962 on the date of bill of entry presentation.

May 10, 2025 CBIC exempts customs duty on certain imports for museums/galleries

Under Section 25(1) of the Customs Act, 1962, CBIC has granted full duty exemption on:

  1. Works of art (including statuary, pictures)
  2. Public memorials and materials for their construction.
  3. Antiques under the Antiquities & Art Treasures Act.

Conditions:

  • Importer must be a museum or art gallery (owner/purchaser).
  • Goods must be for public display only, not for sale.
  • Certificate from an Authorized Officer (Ministry of Culture) confirming open access and proper premises.
  • Antiques must be registered with ASI within 90 days.

June 2025

June 17, 2025

DGFT Notification No. 17/2025-26

Export of Pharma Grade Sugar Key Conditions (25,000 MT cap) Quota: 25,000 MT For sugar season ending September 30, 2025; only for bona fide pharma exporters.

Documents

Valid Drug Manufacturing License (State Authority) NABL-accredited lab test reports & certification meeting pharma-grade specs

Application

Online between 20 June 2025 – 20 July 2025.

One application per IEC; no physical copies.

Allocation

Quota distributed pro-rata based on production capacity.

Direct Tax Rulings

April 2025

M/s. Indo Global Education Foundation vs. DCIT [2025] ITA no 26 (ITAT Chandigarh) Issue

Whether the assessee, was eligible to claim exemptions under Section 11 and 12AA of the IT Act, despite alleged non-compliance with the statutory conditions for charitable institutions.

Observations

  • The Chandigarh ITAT observed that for an entity to avail exemptions under Sections 11 and 12AA, it must strictly adhere to the conditions prescribed, including proper application of income towards charitable purposes and maintenance of adequate documentation.
  • The Tribunal emphasized that exemptions cannot be granted in the absence of clear compliance and substantiation of charitable activities.

Evidence Submitted:

The assessee submitted its audited financial statements, details of income and expenditure, and records related to charitable activities. However, certain claims lacked proper supporting documentation, and there were procedural lapses in applying the income as per statutory mandates.

Outcome

  • The ITAT partially upheld the Revenue’s contentions.
  • It disallowed exemption claims where deficiencies in documentation and compliance were found, while granting relief for the components where the assessee demonstrated sufficient compliance.
  • The ITAT underscored the importance of substantiating tax-exempt income with proper records.

M/s. Anand Diagnostic Laboratory Vs DCIT [2025] ITA Nos.968 & 969/Bang/2024 (ITAT Bangalore) Issue

Whether revaluation of goodwill and reconstitution of a partnership firm, without any actual transfer or withdrawal of assets, triggers capital gains tax under Section 45(4) of the Income-tax Act.

Observation

The Bangalore ITAT observed that mere revaluation of assets and admission of a new partner does not amount to a “transfer” under Section 45(4). The reconstituted firm continued its business, and no capital asset or benefit was distributed to any partner.

Evidence Submitted

Partnership deed reflecting reconstitution and Capital account statements showing no withdrawal.

Outcome

The ITAT held that Section 45(4) was not applicable, as there was no transfer of capital assets and no benefit accrued to the new partner. Revaluation and reconstitution alone do not give rise to capital gains.

May 2025

M/s. British Agro Products (India) Pvt. Ltd Vs. The PCIT [2025] T.C.A.No.499 and 500 of 2023 and C.M.P.No.22213 of 2023 (HC Madras) Issue

Whether income from growing and selling button mushrooms in a factory-controlled, soil-less environment qualifies as “agricultural income” exempt under Section 10(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

Observation

The High Court held that agricultural income must be derived from land used for agricultural purposes. Cultivation in trays within a regulated factory setting lacks the necessary land nexus. The Court found that the ITAT failed to evaluate whether the Assessee's activity met the criteria under Section 2(1A)(a), (b), or (c) of the IT Act.

Evidence submitted

  • The Assessee originally filed its return for AY 2017–18 declaring income under the head "business income." Subsequently, the Assessee filed a revised return under Section 139(4), claiming the entire income as agricultural income exempt under Section 10(1).
  • In support of its revised position, the Assessee relied on the Special Bench ruling of the ITAT in the case of M/s. Inventaa Industries Pvt Ltd Vs. DCIT [2015] ITA No. 1015 to 1018/Hyd/2015, wherein mushroom cultivation was held to qualify as agricultural income.

Outcome

  • The Court ruled against the Assessee, holding that the income from mushroom cultivation in a factory environment was not agricultural income. The revised return claiming exemption under Section 10(1) was held to be legally unsustainable.
  • The Court clarified that industrial cultivation methods without land nexus fall outside the scope of Section 2(1A), making the income taxable as business profits.

June 2025

M/s. Kavita Manoj Damani v. ITO [2024] ITA No. 2648 (MUM.) OF 2024 (ITAT Mumbai) Issue

Whether exemption under Section 54 of the IT Act can be denied when the Assessee purchases a new residential flat from her husband, amidst allegations of circular fund movement and tax evasion.

Observation

  • The Tribunal held that the exemption under Section 54 of the IT Act could not be denied solely because the seller of the new property was the Assessee’s husband or because of temporary fund movement through a company where both were directors.
  • It emphasized that what mattered was the genuineness of ownership, the timeline of reinvestment, and tax compliance.

Evidence submitted

  • The Assessee furnished valid documentation showing acquisition of the two original flats through registered agreements and a gift deed, establishing her individual ownership.
  • The sale proceeds from the two flats were credited to the Assessee’s bank account, temporarily routed through AEPL (a company where both husband and wife were directors), and then paid to her husband for the purchase of the new flat.
  • Documentary evidence showed that TDS was deducted by AEPL on the payment made to the husband, and the tax was duly deposited with the government.

Outcome

The ITAT ruled in favour of the Assessee, granting relief under Section 54 of the IT Act. It held that all legal conditions for claiming exemption were met, and the involvement of a related party or intermediary (AEPL) did not invalidate the transaction. The exemption could not be denied on mere suspicion of tax evasion without substantive evidence.

M/s. Manjeet Singh Chawla Vs. Deputy commissioner of TDS and CIT WPN. 20212 OF 2023 [2025] (HC Karnataka) Issue

Whether a one-time compensation received by an employee for the diminution in value of unexercised ESOPs is taxable as salary/perquisite under Section 17(2)(vi) or is to be treated as a non-taxable capital receipt.

Observations

  • The High Court observed that ESOPs represent a capital right part of the employee's long-term profit-making apparatus and not a routine component of salary.
  • Compensation received for the diminution in value of unexercised ESOPs affects the employee’s capital structure, not income earned as salary.

Evidence submitted

  • The Assessee received a one-time compensation due to the devaluation of ESOPs that were granted but remained unexercised at the time of a corporate event.
  • The employer paid the amount as a compensatory settlement for the loss in value of the ESOPs there was no exercise of option, no transfer, and no consideration for services rendered.
  • The Assessee contended that ESOPs are capital assets under Section 2(14), and that the compensation received on account of their devaluation is a capital receipt. Revenue relied on: M/s. Nishith Kumar Mehta Vs. DCIT, W.P.No.26506 of 2023 (Madras HC), where certain ESOP-related receipts were taxed as salary.
  • Assessee relied on: Sanjay Baweja Vs. DCIT [2024] W.P. No.11155 of 2023 (Delhi HC), where compensation for surrendered or devalued ESOPs was held to be a capital receipt.

Outcome

The High Court ruled that the one-time ESOP compensation was a capital receipt and not subject to income-tax under the head "salary" or as a perquisite. It directed the issuance of a Nil TDS Certificate within six weeks and clarified that no withholding was applicable on this non- taxable capital amount.

Indirect Tax Rulings

April 2025

M/s. TLG India (P.) Ltd.vs. Union of India [2025] WP NO. 5138 OF 2024 (Bombay HC) Issues

  • Whether the GST demand on export transactions was sustainable despite the clarifying CBIC Circular.
  • Whether the tax demand on ESOP Cross recharge could be upheld without allowing the Assessee to submit supporting documents.

Facts

  • TLG India (P.) Ltd. received a GST demand of INR 19.8 crore – INR 18.91 crore for exports and INR 87.91 lakh for ESOPs.
  • For the ESOP issue, the Assessee claimed no extra consideration was received and was not given an opportunity to submit documents
  • The Assessee challenged the order, stating that the CBIC Circular No. 230/24/2024-GST dated September 10,2024, which clarified export taxability, was not considered by the authorities.
  • The Court found a violation of natural justice and remanded the matter for fresh consideration, directing the authorities to examine the circular and documents.

Observations

  • The authority failed to consider CBIC Circular No. 230/24/2024-GST, which clarified that qualifying export services are zero-rated; notably, similar demands were dropped in later periods based on this very circular.
  • The Assessee’s claim that no extra consideration was paid to the Holding Company under the ESOP and the same was rejected without notice or opportunity to submit documents - violating principles of natural justice.
  • The petitioner further contended that the transaction was eligible for full input tax credit (ITC) and, therefore, the value of supply should be treated as ‘Nil’ in accordance with Rule 28 of the CGST Rules, as clarified by CBIC Circular No. 199/11/2023-GST. However, the adjudicating authority neither considered nor addressed this specific plea in the impugned order.

Outcome

  • The High Court quashed the GST demand order and remanded the case for fresh adjudication, citing non-consideration of CBIC Circular and violation of natural justice in the ESOP issue.
  • It directed that the Assessee be given a full opportunity to present documents and arguments.

M/s. Indian Medical Association vs. Union of India [2025] W.A.NO.1659 OF 2024 (Kerala HC) Issues

  • Whether GST can be levied on services provided by a members’ association (IMA) to its own members under the amended Section 7(1)(aa) of the CGST Act.
  • Whether the principle of mutuality, upheld by the Supreme Court in Calcutta Club Ltd., continues to apply post the Finance Act, 2021.
  • Whether retrospective application of Section 7(1)(aa) from 01.07.2017 is constitutional.

Facts

  • The Indian Medical Association (IMA), Kerala branch, offered mutual benefit schemes to member doctors and was served GST summons and notices for FY 2017–2022.
  • IMA argued that these were internal welfare activities and thus covered by the principle of mutuality, hence not liable to GST.
  • The Finance Act, 2021 amended Section 7 of the CGST Act to include transactions between associations and members as taxable "supply", with retrospective effect.

May 2025

M/s. Indian Medical Association vs. Union of India [2025] W.A.NO.1659 OF 2024 (Kerala HC) Observations

  • The Court noted that the principle of mutuality survives under the Constitution, even post the 46th Constitutional Amendment, as held in Calcutta Club Ltd.
  • It held that Parliament cannot override this principle via a deeming fiction in a statute without a constitutional amendment.
  • Retrospective application from 2017 was found to be unfair, arbitrary, and confiscatory, placing unreasonable burdens on associations like IMA.

Outcome

  • Section 7(1)(aa) of the CGST Act and related deeming provisions were struck down as unconstitutional to the extent they nullify mutuality.
  • GST cannot be levied on services by a members’ club/association to its members where mutuality applies.

M/s. IDP Education India Pvt Ltd vs Union of India [2025] W.P. NO. 5144 OF 2022 AND W.P. NO.2774 OF 2024 (HC Bombay) Issues

  • Whether the services rendered by IDP Education India to its parent company in Australia qualify as “intermediary services” under Section 13(8) read with Section 2(13) of the IGST Act.
  • Whether the taxpayer is eligible for GST refund on such services, treating them as exports.
  • Whether past CESTAT rulings and CBIC Circulars remain applicable under GST.

M/s. IDP Education India Pvt Ltd vs Union of India [2025] W.P. NO. 5144 OF 2022 AND W.P. NO.2774 OF 2024 (HC Bombay) Issues Facts

  • IDP India, a subsidiary of IDP Australia, provides student recruitment support services to IDP Australia for Indian students enrolling in foreign universities.
  • Revenue denied refund of IGST (~INR 9.73 crore over two years) claiming IDP India acted as an "intermediary".
  • IDP India had no contracts with students or foreign universities and only serviced its parent under a bi-party agreement; it relied on a favorable CESTAT ruling from the pre-GST era and CBIC Circular No. 159/15/2021-GST.

Observations

  • The Court carefully examined the nature of the agreement and noted that although the Support Services Agreement was renewed periodically, the scope of services remained identical across both the service tax and GST regimes.
  • The Court placed strong reliance on the CESTAT’s Final Order dated 28 October 2021, which had conclusively held that IDP India was not an "intermediary" under the service tax regime, the High Court observed that there was no justification for a contrary interpretation under GST, especially when the facts remained unchanged.
  • The Court also noted the clarification issued by CBIC via Circular No. 159/15/2021-GST dated 20.09.2021, which explicitly stated that the definition and scope of "intermediary" under GST continues to mirror that under the service tax regime.

Outcome

IDP India is not an intermediary as it provides backend support to its parent without direct contracts with students or universities. Its services are exports under IGST law, and thus eligible for refund. The matter was remanded for refund processing with interest.

M/s. HMSU Rollers (India) Pvt. Ltd. [2025] Advance Ruling No. GUJ/GAAR/R/2025/15 Issues

  • Whether PEB qualifies as 'plant and machinery' to allow ITC under Section 17(5) CGST Act.
  • Eligibility of ITC on construction-related inputs and services for a factory building was treated as immovable property.
  • Whether capital goods embedded into structure (like rails, electrification for crane) qualify for proportionate ITC or get blocked under Section 17(5)(c) & (d).

Facts

  • The taxpayer undertook a factory expansion requiring installation of a Pre-Engineered Building (PEB), designed to support a 10-ton overhead crane.
  • The PEB was claimed to be a "multi-utility" structure functioning as plant and machinery, given its design integration with crane operations.
  • The applicant sought an Advance Ruling on eligibility of proportionate ITC on:
  • Inputs like steel, cement
  • Input services such as erection and installation
  • Capital goods like rails and electrification equipment used in crane setup.

Observations

  • AAR held that despite the crane’s dependency on the PEB structure, the PEB remains a civil structure, not qualifying as plant and machinery.
  • The supply and services used in constructing immovable property are blocked unless falling under the defined exception for "plant and machinery.“
  • The ruling heavily relied on the SC decision in Safari Retreats and the retrospective amendment by Finance Act 2025, which clarified that ITC is blocked for “plant or machinery” to be read strictly as “plant and machinery” and excludes civil structures.

M/s. HMSU Rollers (India) Pvt. Ltd. [2025] Advance Ruling No. GUJ/GAAR/R/2025/15 Outcome

The Gujarat AAR held that ITC is not available on inputs, input services, and capital goods used for constructing a PEB-based factory, treating it as immovable property under Section 17(5). The ruling relied on the Supreme Court decision in Safari Retreats. rejecting prior AAR interpretations.

June 2025

M/s. SICPA India Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India [2025] WP (C) NO. 54 OF 2023 (Sikkim HC) Facts

  • The Assessee’s GST registration was cancelled due to closure of business, and a refund of unutilized ITC was claimed.
  • The refund was rejected, and the Appellate Authority held that Section 54(3) allows refunds only in two specified scenarios.

Issues

  • Whether refund of unutilized ITC is permissible under Section 49(6) read with Section 54 when a business shuts down and registration is cancelled.
  • Whether Section 54(3) restricts refunds only to zero-rated supplies or inverted duty structure, thereby excluding closure cases.

Observations

  • The Court held that while Section 54(3) specifies two situations, there is no express bar on refund under Section 49(6) for business closure.
  • Relying on Slovak India and other precedents, it ruled that tax cannot be retained without legal authority, even if business operations cease.

Outcome

  • Refund of unutilized ITC cannot be denied merely because the business is discontinued, or registration is cancelled.
  • The Court allowed the refund claim in favour of the Assessee.

www.soliqueadvisors.com

[email protected]

Keep a copy for reference

Download the original Solique Advisors publication.

PDF · 13 pages · 2.2 MB
Back to all publications