Domestic Tax Updates & Key Rulings Q4 of FY 2025-26 — Domestic Tax Pulse

India’s direct and indirect tax developments for Q4 of FY 2025-26, including notifications, compliance updates and key rulings.

By Chirag Baid31 min readnewsletter

PDF · 20 pages · 2.3 MB

Original PDF cover for Domestic Tax Updates & Key Rulings Q4 of FY 2025-26 — Domestic Tax Pulse
The original Solique Advisors publication
In this publication

Note From CEO

Dear Readers,

As we conclude Q4 of FY 2025–26, we are pleased to present this edition of our Domestic Tax Pulse, capturing key legislative, administrative, and judicial developments shaping India’s evolving tax framework.

This quarter reflects a clear shift towards a digitally driven, enforcement-oriented, and structurally simplified tax regime. The introduction of the Income-tax Rules, 2026, along with targeted CBDT clarifications and procedural reforms, indicates a move towards greater alignment between law and administration, reducing ambiguity while strengthening compliance architecture. At the same time, expanded reporting frameworks (including digital assets), DIN-based authentication, and GAAR rationalisation underscore a strong focus on transparency, traceability, and certainty, while continuing to protect legacy positions.

From an indirect tax perspective, reforms continue to balance ease of doing business with robust oversight, supported by digitised systems, streamlined customs processes, and risk- based mechanisms. Judicial trends across both direct and indirect taxes reinforce the principle of substance over form, with courts consistently prioritising economic reality, factual conduct, and legislative intent whether in matters of residency, exemptions, transaction characterisation, or taxpayer rights.

At Solique Advisors, our focus remains on translating these developments into practical, insight-driven guidance. In an environment defined by increasing precision and regulatory convergence, proactive compliance, strong documentation, and strategic clarity are essential to navigating risks and unlocking sustainable value.

With regards,

Chirag Baid
Co-Founder & CEO, Solique Group

Direct Tax Updates

February 2026

The Finance Act, 2026 received Presidential assent on March 30, 2026. For key snippets and a detailed analysis, refer to our Budget publication dated February 1, 2026.

March 2026

March 05, 2026 Notification No. 19/2026 CRS / Reporting Rules amended – Rules 114F, 114G, 114H - w.e.f. January 1,2026

Digital assets are now covered: The scope of reportable financial accounts has been expanded to include crypto-assets, digital wallets (e-money), and CBDCs, meaning these are now treated similar to traditional financial accounts for reporting purposes.

Who needs to report: The obligations apply to Reporting Financial Institutions, which broadly include banks (depository institutions), custodial institutions, investment entities (including fund managers), insurance companies issuing certain investment-linked policies, and now also entities dealing with e-money and digital assets in specified cases.

Enhanced reporting obligations: RFIs are required to capture additional data points, including self-certification status, controlling persons, joint account details, and classification of accounts (new vs pre-existing), leading to greater transparency.

Exemption from reporting: The rules align with CRS and CARF frameworks, avoid duplication of crypto reporting, and provide targeted reliefs, including:

  • Threshold-based exclusion for low-value e-money accounts (USD 10,000).

  • Transitional relaxation for pre-existing accounts (reporting only if data is electronically available).

March 20, 2026

The Government has notified the Income-tax Rules, 2026, comprising of 333 rules, replacing the earlier framework of over 511 rules to operationalise the provisions of new IT Act, 2025.

March 23, 2026 Circular No. 01/2026 Condonation of delay in filing Form 10A – Authority clarified

  • Core issue – mismatch between law and procedure: Post amendment effective October 1, 2024, Section 12A(1)(ac) of the IT Act, 1961 empowers the jurisdictional PCIT/CIT to condone delays in filing Form 10A; however, since Rule 17A of the IT Rules,1962 continues to provide for processing of such applications by CPC, Bengaluru, this has led to a procedural inconsistency between statutory provisions and procedural framework.
  • Resulting ambiguity and implementation challenges: In the absence of clarity, taxpayers were uncertain whether condonation applications were to be made before CPC or jurisdictional PCIT/CIT, leading to inconsistent practices, delays in processing, and in certain cases, risk of denial of exemption purely on procedural grounds.
  • CBDT clarification: The Board has now clarified that the power to condone delay vests exclusively with the jurisdictional PCIT/CIT, notwithstanding CPC’s role being limited to processing and granting registration.

March 31, 2026 Circular No. 4/2026 Referencing by Document Identification Number (DIN) – Revised framework

Framework updated with statutory backing: CBDT has revised the DIN regime, replacing Circular 19/2019, in line with insertion of Section 292BA of the IT Act, 1961 and corresponding provisions under the IT Act, 2025.

Mandatory DIN for taxpayer communications: All communications (notice, order, summons, letters) issued to taxpayers must carry a DIN, ensuring authenticity, traceability, and system- based validation.

Mode of quoting DIN clarified: DIN requirement is satisfied if mentioned in the communication, email, or as a separate attachment; not required on every page, reducing procedural rigidity

Exclusion for public communications: General instructions such as guidelines, circulars, FAQs are kept outside the DIN requirement.

Takeaway: The circular operationalises statutory backing under Section 292BA of the IT Act, 1961 by tightening the DIN framework, restricting exceptions, and ensuring that only duly authenticated communications are treated as valid, thereby reducing litigation on invalid notices.

March 31, 2026 CBDT Notification No. 54/2026 and 55/2026 – GAAR applicability carve-out

  • Amendment to GAAR carve-out for pre-2017 investments: Rule 128 and Rule 10U of IT Rules,1962 have been amended to clarify that any income arising to a person from the transfer of investments made before April 1,2017 shall not be subject to GAAR.

  • Clarification on applicability of GAAR post-April 1, 2017: Rule 128(2) of IT Rules,1962 has been substituted to provide that GAAR provisions shall apply to any arrangement, irrespective of the date of entering into such arrangement, where the tax benefit arises on or after April 01, 2017.

  • Exception retained for grandfathered investments: Despite the above, a specific exception is carved out such that income from transfer of investments made before April 01, 2017, continues to remain outside the ambit of GAAR, even if such income arises after April 01, 2017. The amendment is effective from April 01, 2026.

  • Intent: The amendments reaffirm the Government’s commitment to protect legacy investments while maintaining the effectiveness of GAAR for post-2017 arrangements. This provides certainty to taxpayers holding pre-2017 investments and ensures that anti-abuse provisions are not applied retrospectively.

Indirect Tax Updates

January 2026

January 02, 2026 Trade Notice No. 21/2025-26 DGFT Trade Notice: Collateral Support for Export Credit under Export Promotion Mission (EPM) – NIRYAT PROTSAHAN

The DGFT has launched a collateral support scheme to improve access to export credit for MSME exporters facing collateral constraints. The initiative aims to enhance credit flow, reduce lending risk, and strengthen export competitiveness, and is operationalised through CGTMSE with immediate effect.

ParametersDetails
Guarantee Coverage• Micro & Small - 85% • Medium - 65% via Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises
Maximum LimitUp to INR 10 crore per exporter for FY 2025–26
Type of FacilityExport-linked working capital (Pre & Post shipment)
Sector ApplicabilityRestricted to notified HSN tariff goods
MSME ManufacturersEligible
Merchant ExportersEligible – with valid IEC
RegistrationUdyam Registration mandatory

Compliance framework:

  • File intent on DGFT portal and UIN generated.
  • Approach bank for export credit.
  • Bank applies to Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises.
  • Pay guarantee fees and guarantee cover issued.

This initiative is expected to significantly ease collateral constraints for MSME exporters, by improving access to institutional credit.

January 30, 2026 Health Security se National Security Cess (First Amendment) Rules, 2026

The Central Government has notified the First Amendment to the Health Security se National Security Cess Rules, 2026 to standardise machine capacity determination, streamline abatement provisions, and formalise utilisation of cess collections. The amendments are effective from February 01, 2026.

Key amendments:

  • Machine capacity determination: A formula has been prescribed to compute the “maximum rated speed” of packing machines based on RPM, gear ratio, and number of cups/funnels, ensuring a uniform basis for cess liability.

  • Abatement mechanism rationalised: Where machines remain non-operational for more than 15 days, abatement shall be computed proportionately and allowed as an adjustment against subsequent cess liability.

  • Utilisation framework: Cess collections shall be credited to the Consolidated Fund of India and periodically transferred to a dedicated fund for utilisation towards public health and national security purposes.

Procedural refinements:

  • Terminology aligned (replacement of “tracks” with “cups”).
  • Clarifications in computation fields and column references.
  • Revised guidance for Chartered Engineer certification.
  • Correction of statutory references in forms.

The amendments enhance clarity in capacity- based levy, reduce ambiguity in abatement claims, and strengthen transparency in utilisation of cess, improving overall compliance.

February 2026

February 01, 2026 Notification No. 14/2026–Customs (N.T.) Customs Notification: Baggage Rules, 2026

The Government has notified the Baggage Rules, 2026, replacing the earlier Baggage Rules, 2016, to streamline duty-free allowances, clarify eligibility conditions, and align provisions relating to passenger baggage. The rules are effective from February 02, 2026.

Highlights:

Duty-free allowance framework:

Passengers are allowed duty-free clearance of used personal effects and bona fide baggage, with a general free allowance of up to INR 75,000 (INR 25,000 for foreign tourists), subject to specified exclusions.

Specific inclusions/exclusions: Items such as firearms, excess tobacco/alcohol, gold (other than jewellery), and televisions are excluded from duty-free benefits.

Jewellery allowance: Returning Indian residents can bring jewellery duty-free up to prescribed weight limits (higher limit for female passengers).

Transfer of residence benefit:

Enhanced duty-free limits are available for individuals shifting residence to India, subject to duration of stay and specified conditions.

Other provisions:

  • One laptop allowed duty-free.
  • Temporary import and re-import provisions clarified.
  • Rules extended to unaccompanied baggage and crew members.

The new rules provide clarity on passenger entitlements, rationalise duty-free limits, and improve ease of compliance for international travelers.

February 06,2026 DGFT Trade Notice No. 23/2025–26 NPCI-based Bank Account Validation for IEC Applications

DGFT had earlier, vide Public Notice No. 32/2025- 26 dated November 20, 2025, enabled online API-based validation of IEC-related details through integration with Government and authenticated databases. To further facilitate above and strengthen the IEC ecosystem the DGFT integrated with the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) for real-time bank account validation.

NPCI integration introduced: Bank account details furnished in IEC applications will now be validated in real-time through NPCI, ensuring correct linkage of PAN, name, and bank account details.

Mandatory declaration: Applicants are required to declare all active bank accounts linked with PAN and ensure accurate matching with bank records.

System-driven processing:

  • Success: Application proceeds normally.
  • In Progress: Application placed under automatic review and approved upon successful validation.
  • Failed: Application cannot be submitted or is rejected/marked deficient based on stage.

Intent: Introduces real-time bank validation in IEC processes to improve data accuracy and streamline application approvals.

February 28,2026 CBIC Circular No. 08/2026–Customs Deferred Payment of Duty extended to Eligible Manufacturer Importers (EMI)

The CBIC has operationalised the extension of deferred payment of customs duty to “Eligible Manufacturer Importers (EMI)” to facilitate faster clearance and improve liquidity for compliant importers. The facility will be effective from April 01,2026 and available up to March 31, 2028.

Scope of benefit: Eligible Manufacturer Importers can avail deferred payment of customs duty in accordance with the Deferred Payment of Import Duty Rules, 2016, enabling payment on a deferred basis instead of upfront at the time of clearance.

Eligibility conditions: Applicants must satisfy prescribed criteria including:

  • Valid IEC and active GST registration.
  • Minimum customs transaction threshold (25 documents / 10 for MSMEs).
  • Turnover exceeding INR 5 crore.
  • Minimum 2 years of business operations.
  • Clean compliance track record (no defaults, prosecutions, or insolvency).

Application process:

I. Application to be filed online on AEO portal from March 01, 2026.

II. Approval granted by Directorate of International Customs (DIC).

III. Post-approval, facility enabled automatically in Customs system.

Operational mechanism:

  • Importers must select deferred payment option (“D”) in Bill of Entry.
  • Authentication through ICEGATE login by authorised nodal person.
  • Duty payment due by 1st of following month.

Monitoring and controls:

Customs authorities will monitor usage and compliance, with power to suspend or revoke eligibility in case of non-compliance.

March 2026

March 10, 2026 GSTAT Instructions: Filing of Appeals and Scrutiny Requirements

GSTAT has issued procedural instructions prescribing documentation and scrutiny requirements for filing appeals, with a focus on standardising filings through Form APL-05 and reducing defects during scrutiny.

Requirements for taxpayers:

APL-05 must be filed with soft copies of the following:

  • Show Cause Notice (SCN)
  • Order-in-Original (OIO)
  • Order-in-Appeal (OIA)
  • Statement of facts and grounds of appeal

Pre-deposit and court fees are mandatory. However, no defect shall be raised where exemption is supported by orders of higher courts.

Where certified copies of OIO/OIA are uploaded and duly endorsed by issuing authorities, no defect should be raised if the scrutiny officer is satisfied with the certification.

Taxpayers are also required to upload:

  • Authorisation in favour of tax professional, or
  • Vakalatnama in case of an advocate.

Requirements for departmental appeals:

  • Appeals filed by the Department must include:
  • SCN, OIO, and OIA.
  • Commissioner’s opinion authorising filing of appeal.
  • Statement of facts and grounds of appeal.
  • No court fee or pre-deposit is required for such appeals.

Direct Tax Rulings

January 2026

DTAA Denied – Indirect Transfer Held Taxable in India

Authority for Advance Rulings v. Tiger Global International Holdings (II, III & IV) [2026] CIVIL APPEAL NO. 262 OF 2026 (SC)

Issue

Whether capital gains arising to Mauritius entities from the sale of shares of a Singapore company (Flipkart holding entity) deriving substantial value from Indian assets are:

  • Taxable in India as indirect transfer, and
  • Whether DTAA benefits (India–Mauritius) can be denied on grounds of treaty shopping, lack of commercial substance and control being outside Mauritius.

Facts

  • Assessees: Mauritius entities of Tiger Global Group.
  • Investment made in Flipkart Singapore entity (2011–2015).
  • Shares sold in 2018 to a Luxembourg entity as a part of Walmart deal.
  • Value of shares derived substantially from Indian assets.
  • Assessees claimed:
    • DTAA protection.
    • Grandfathering (pre-April 1, 2017 investments).
  • Revenue argued:
    • Structure is designed for tax avoidance.
    • Entities lack commercial substance.
    • Control lies outside Mauritius.
  • Tax Residency Certificates (TRC) issued by Mauritius authorities to establish treaty eligibility.
  • Corporate structure and investment routing through Mauritius, Singapore, and other jurisdictions.
  • Board resolutions, financial statements, and organisational structure to demonstrate control and management.
  • India – Mauritius DTAA (Article 13, including grandfathering provisions.)
  • CBDT Circular No. 789 regarding reliance on TRC.
  • Judicial precedents: Azadi Bachao Andolan (validity of treaty shopping & TRC) and Vodafone International Holdings (indirect transfer & substance over form).
  • OECD principles and “substance over form / beneficial ownership” tests.

Observations

  • The Court examined Article 13 of the India– Mauritius DTAA and held that the exemption for capital gains is intended for transfer of shares of an Indian company; in the present case, the transfer was of shares of a Singapore entity, thereby falling outside the treaty’s direct scope.

  • Since the shares derived substantial value from Indian assets, the transaction qualified as an indirect transfer taxable in India under Section 9(1)(i).

  • A DTAA does not prevent the Revenue from examining treaty abuse; domestic anti- avoidance principles, including GAAR and substance over form, can be invoked where the arrangement lacks commercial substance.

  • While a TRC is relevant evidence of residence, it is not conclusive in cases where surrounding facts indicate possible conduit arrangements or lack of beneficial ownership.

  • On facts, the structure indicated that the Mauritian entities were investment holding vehicles with limited independent control, and key decisions were effectively taken outside Mauritius.

  • The Court noted that mere compliance with legal form (incorporation, TRC, documentation) is insufficient where the economic substance and control do not align.

  • Treaty shopping, though permissible, cannot extend to arrangements structured primarily to obtain unintended tax benefits.

  • The benefit of grandfathering for pre-April 01, 2017 investments was held to be inapplicable, as the transaction itself was outside treaty protection and formed part of an avoidance-driven structure.

Outcome / Held

  • Assessees not entitled to DTAA benefit.
  • Capital gains held taxable in India as indirect transfer.
  • TRC and treaty protection denied in view of lack of commercial substance / treaty abuse.
  • High Court ruling set aside; Revenue’s position upheld.

Substance Over Stay – ITAT Rejects Non- Resident Claim and Denies DTAA Benefit

Binny Bansal v. DCIT [2026] IT(IT)A No.571/Bang/2023 (Bangalore ITAT)

Issue

Whether the Assessee (Flipkart co-founder) qualifies as a non-resident under Section 6 for FY 2019–20 and consequently eligible to claim benefit under India–Singapore DTAA, particularly in respect of capital gains on sale of Flipkart shares.

Facts

  • The Assessee, an Indian citizen and co- founder of Flipkart, claimed non-resident status for AY 2020–21.
  • He had moved to Singapore in February 2019 for employment and claimed that:
    • He was “being outside India”, and
    • His stay in India (141 days) should be tested under the relaxed 182-day threshold under Explanation 1 to Section 6(1)(c).
  • During the year, the Assessee:
    • Sold substantial shares of Flipkart (including transactions with Tiger Global and others).
    • Claimed such gains were not taxable in India under Article 13(5) of the India–Singapore DTAA.
  • The Assessing Officer held that:
    • Assessee was resident in India under Section 6(1)(c).
    • DTAA benefit not available.
    • Capital gains taxable in India.
  • DRP upheld the AO’s findings.

Assessee relied on:

  • Explanation 1(b) to Section 6(1)(c) (relaxation to 182 days)
  • Employment and relocation to Singapore
  • DTAA tie-breaker (Article 4):
    • Permanent home in Singapore,
    • Centre of vital interest in Singapore.

Revenue relied on:

  • Section 6(1)(c) – basic residency test
  • Legislative intent behind Explanation 1 (benefit only for genuine non-residents)
  • DTAA tie-breaker factors:
    • Permanent home,
    • Centre of vital interest,
    • Economic and personal relations.

Observations

1. Interpretation of “Being Outside India”

  • ITAT held that Explanation 1(b) applies only to individuals already qualifying as non- residents, not to those attempting to avoid residency.

  • The phrase “being outside India” cannot be equated with mere travel or relocation.

  • Relaxation from 60 days to 182 days applies:

    • Only in the year of departure from India, and
    • Not in subsequent years.

2. Residential Status under Section 6(1)(c)

  • Assessee satisfied both conditions:
    • Stay >60 days in relevant FY (141 days)
    • Stay >365 days in preceding 4 years (1237 days)
  • Accordingly, held to be Resident in India.

3. Rejection of Treaty Residency (DTAA – Article 4) (a) Permanent Home Test

  • Assessee owned/maintained multiple residential properties in India.
  • Singapore accommodation not conclusively established and therefore permanent home closer to India.

(b) Centre of Vital Interest

  • Major investments, business interests, and economic activity linked to India.
  • Flipkart-related wealth and operations substantially India-centric and therefore Economic nexus strongly in India.

(c) Habitual Abode & Nationality

Long-term residence, nationality, and life history rooted in India - Tie-breaker favours India.

4. Substance Over Form Principle

Tribunal emphasised that residential status cannot be manipulated by timing of travel or structuring of stay and Substance of economic and personal ties is decisive.

5. Legislative Intent Behind Residency Provisions

Provisions designed to prevent artificial arrangements and perpetual avoidance of residency status that accepting Assessee’s argument would allow recurring misuse of 182-day relaxation every year.

Outcome / Held

  • Assessee held to be Resident in India under Section 6(1)(c).
  • Not eligible for Explanation 1 relaxation.
  • DTAA tie-breaker test also results in India residency.
  • Capital gains taxable in India.

February 2026

No TDS on ECB Facilitation Fees – ‘Make Available’ Condition Not Satisfied

CIT v. TVS Motor Company Ltd. [2026] T.C.(A).No.330 of 2011 (Madras High Court)

Issue

Whether payments made to foreign entities for facilitating External Commercial Borrowings (ECB) constitute Fees for Technical Services (FTS) liable for TDS under Section 195, and consequent disallowance under Section 40(a)(i), particularly where no technical know-how is “made available” under the applicable DTAAs.

Facts

  • Assessee made payments (INR 6.62 crore) to UK entity (Asia Pacific Investments PLC) and Singapore entity (Regional Capital Pte Ltd).
  • Payments were towards facilitating ECB.
  • No TDS was deducted under Section 195
  • Assessee’s position: Payments are business income, not taxable in India (no PE).
  • AO’s position:
    • Services are technical in nature and taxable as FTS.
    • Disallowance made under Section 40(a)(i).
  • CIT(A): Held services are technical, but and no taxability under DTAA as know-how not made available.
  • Agreements and documentation evidencing nature of ECB facilitation services.
  • India–UK DTAA (Article 13) and India– Singapore DTAA (Article 12).
  • “Make available” clause under both treaties.
  • Section 195 and Section 40(a)(i) of the IT Act, 1961.
  • Judicial precedent:
    • De Beers India Minerals Pvt Ltd - make available test.
    • Azadi Bachao Andolan (treaty override under Section 90.

Observations

  • The Court clarified that the services rendered were technical in nature, and the Tribunal erred in holding otherwise.

  • However, under both India–UK and India– Singapore DTAAs, FTS is taxable only where the services “make available” technical knowledge, skill, or know-how to the recipient.

  • The “make available” test requires that the recipient should be able to apply the technology independently in future without the service provider.

  • On facts, the Assessee had merely received facilitation services for obtaining ECB, and there was no transfer of:

    • Technical knowledge.
    • Skill.
    • Process or know-how.
  • It was specifically noted that the Assessee would continue to depend on the service provider for similar transactions in future.

  • Therefore, while services were technical, they did not satisfy the additional threshold under DTAA, and hence did not qualify as FTS.

  • Applying Section 90, the Court held that treaty provisions being more beneficial override domestic law, even if the payment may fall within the wider scope of FTS under the Act.

Outcome / Held

  • Payments not taxable as FTS under DTAA (no “make available”).
  • No obligation to deduct TDS under Section 195.
  • Disallowance under Section 40(a)(i) not applicable.

Substance Over Form – Exemption under Section 56(2)(x) Allowed for Trust Created for Relatives

VS Trust v. ITO [2026] ITA No.2633/Chny/2025 (Chennai ITAT)

Issue

Whether receipt of shares by a private trust from its settlor is taxable under Section 56(2)(x) as income from other sources, or eligible for exemption under the proviso where the trust is created or established solely for the benefit of relatives, particularly in cases where the original trust deed permits inclusion of non- relatives but is subsequently amended.

Facts

  • The Assessee, a private family trust, received shares worth INR 15.78 crore from its settlor without consideration.
  • The Assessee claimed exemption under Section 56(2)(x), stating that the trust was exclusively for relatives.
  • The Assessing Officer relied on the original trust deed, which allowed addition of entities controlled by relatives, and held that this created a possibility of benefit to non- relatives.
  • On this basis, the AO taxed the entire receipt as income. The CIT(A) upheld the addition, rejecting the validity of the amended trust deed.

I. Assessee relied on:

  • Proviso to Section 56(2)(x)(c) – exemption for trusts solely for relatives.
  • Definition of “relative” under Explanation to Section 56(2)(vii).
  • Supplementary trust deed deleting clause permitting addition of non-relatives.
  • Judicial principle: assessment to be based on actual beneficiaries and real facts, not hypothetical possibilities.

II. Revenue relied on:

  • Original trust deed provisions enabling addition of entities.
  • Potential indirect benefit to non-relatives.
  • Strict interpretation of exemption provisions.

Observations

  • The Tribunal reiterated that exemption under Section 56(2)(x) applies only where the trust is exclusively for relatives, and this condition must be strictly satisfied.

  • However, the AO’s conclusion was based on a hypothetical possibility arising from the original clause, rather than the actual structure of the trust.

  • The Tribunal noted that:

    Clause 5.2 of the original trust deed had been validly substituted by a supplemental deed, effective from inception.

    The amended clause removed the power to add non-relatives or entities, thereby restricting beneficiaries strictly to relatives.

  • On validity of amendment:

    The Tribunal held that the amendment was permissible under the trust deed, as it did not alter the object of the trust or confer control back to the settlor.

    Instead, it reinforced the original intent of a family trust.

  • On beneficiary test:

    • All actual beneficiaries were relatives of the settlor.
    • No non-relative had been added or benefited.
  • The Tribunal rejected the Revenue’s approach of relying on potential or contingent scenarios, holding that taxability must be based on actual facts and valid governing documents.

Outcome / Held

  • The trust was held to be created solely for the benefit of relatives.
  • The amendment to the trust deed was held to be valid.
  • Receipt of shares amounting to INR 15.78 crore was held not taxable under Section 56(2)(x).
  • Separate addition of INR 12 crore (advance tax paid by settlor) was also deleted, as it was a repayable liability and not income.

March 2026

Conversion of Agricultural Land to Non- Agricultural Land – Capital Gains Taxability Upheld

Parvathaneni Praveen v. ITO [2026] ITA.No.1271/Hyd/2025 (Hyderabad ITAT)

Issue

Whether land originally acquired as agricultural land but converted into non-agricultural land prior to sale would continue to qualify as “agricultural land” (and hence fall outside the definition of capital asset under Section 2(14)(iii)), thereby not taxable under the head capital gains.

Facts

  • The Assessee purchased agricultural land and later applied for and obtained conversion to non-agricultural land.
  • Despite such conversion, the Assessee contended that agricultural activities (mango cultivation, etc.) continued on the land.
  • The land was subsequently sold for INR 25 lakh, while the stamp duty value was INR 98.69 lakh, triggering Section 50C implications.
  • The Assessee did not report any capital gains, claiming the land was agricultural and hence not a capital asset under Section 2(14).
  • The Assessing Officer treated the land as non- agricultural, invoked Section 50C, and computed long-term capital gains of INR 96.86 lakh.
  • Additions were also made under Section 69A for unexplained cash deposits and credits.
  • Assessee relied on:
    • Evidence of agricultural operations (photographs, land records)
    • Judicial precedents emphasizing actual use of land
  • Revenue relied on:
    • Conversion records indicating change in land character
    • Stamp duty valuation as non- agricultural land
    • Judicial principles that nature of land is determined objectively, not by intention or intermittent use

Observations

  • Conversion decisive for character: The Tribunal held that once the Assessee himself converted the land into non-agricultural land, it loses its agricultural character for tax purposes.

  • Actual use irrelevant post-conversion: Merely continuing agricultural activity does not alter the legal character of land once converted.

  • Buyer’s perspective matters: The consideration paid reflects development potential, not prior agricultural use.

  • Section 2(14) interpretation:

    • Agricultural land is excluded only if it satisfies specific conditions.
    • Non-agricultural land is always a capital asset and no exclusion applies.
  • Substance over activity: The Tribunal emphasized that legal status and classification of land prevail over incidental usage.

  • Additions under Section 69A:

    • Assessee failed to substantiate source of cash deposits (claimed to be wife’s agricultural income).

    • Lack of documentary evidence (ITR, bank statements, confirmations) led to confirmation of additions.

Outcome / Held

  • Land converted into non-agricultural land ceases to qualify as agricultural land for purposes of Section 2(14).
  • Gains on sale taxable as capital gains under Section 50C.
  • Additions under Section 69A upheld due to lack of substantiation.

Share Buy-back within Group Treated as ‘Corporate Reorganisation’ – DTAA Benefit Allowed

Huntsman Investment (Netherlands) BV v. ADIT [2026] ITA NO. 764/DEL/2014 (Delhi ITAT)

Issue

Whether buy-back of shares by an Indian subsidiary from its foreign parent qualifies as a “corporate reorganisation” under Article 13(5) of the India–Netherlands DTAA, thereby making capital gains taxable only in the country of residence (Netherlands) and not in India.

Facts

  • The Assessee (Netherlands entity) held entire stake in its Indian subsidiary (HIIPL).
  • HIIPL undertook a buy-back of shares, resulting in partial exit - 24% stake reduction.
  • The Assessee initially offered capital gains to tax in India, but later claimed:
    • Exemption under Section 47(iv) (transfer to subsidiary), and
    • Alternatively, DTAA benefit under Article 13(5).
  • The TPO made significant upward valuation adjustments, increasing capital gains.
  • DRP rejected both claims (Section 47 + DTAA benefit).
  • Matter reached ITAT, where there was a difference of opinion, referred to a Third Member.

Assessee relied on:

  • Article 13(5) of India–Netherlands DTAA
  • Concept of corporate reorganisation / restructuring
  • ICAI and ICSI guidance recognising buy-back as capital restructuring
  • International treaty interpretation principles (Vienna Convention)

Revenue contended:

  • Buy-back is a taxable transfer under Section 46A.
  • Does not qualify as reorganisation under domestic law.
  • No formal restructuring scheme or court approval.

Observations

  • DTAA structure (Article 13):
    • General rule: Capital gains taxable in residence state (Netherlands)
    • Exception: Source taxation if ≥10% shareholding
    • Exception to exception: If transaction is part of corporate reorganisation, taxation reverts to residence state
  • Meaning of ‘reorganisation’: Not defined in DTAA and same is interpreted using Legal dictionaries, ICAI and ICSI guidance whereby it is concluded that Buy-back recognised as capital restructuring activity
  • Substance of transaction:
    • Transaction occurred within same corporate group
    • Resulted in Change in financial structure, Reduction in shareholding and no change in ultimate ownership/control
  • Interpretation of treaty provisions:
    • Must be purposive, not restrictive
    • Objective: Avoid taxation in source country for intra-group reorganisations
  • Rejection of narrow domestic interpretation:
    • Tribunal held that absence of court- approved scheme is not decisive
    • What matters is economic substance and group restructuring intent

Outcome / Held

  • Buy-back of shares within the group qualifies as “corporate reorganisation” under Article 13(5).
  • Capital gains not taxable in India; taxable only in Netherlands and subseqeuently DTAA benefit is allowed.

Indirect Tax Rulings

January 2026

Exemption on Health Insurance Restricted to Individual Policies — Group Policies Not Eligible

E.P. Gopakumar & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. [2026] WP(C) No. 38316 of 2025 (Kerala High Court, Judgment dated January 8,2026)

Issue

  • Whether GST exemption granted under Notification No. 16/2025–Central Tax (Rate) applies to group health insurance policies issued to bank employees and retirees.
  • Whether such policies can be interpreted as falling outside the definition of “group” and thereby qualify as individual policies for exemption purposes.

Facts

  • The petitioners comprised retired bank employees and pensioners’ associations covered under group medical insurance schemes.
  • These policies were:

Arranged by the Indian Banks’ Association (IBA) through a bidding and negotiation process, Issued by general insurance companies, and Extended to a large pool of serving and retired employees.

  • Pursuant to Notification dated September 17,2025 (issued based on 56th GST Council recommendations), GST exemption was introduced for certain health insurance services.
  • Insurers continued to levy GST @18% on group policy premiums, which was challenged by the petitioners.
  • Petitioners contended that:
    • Their grouping existed solely for availing insurance, and
    • Hence, they should not be treated as a “group” within the meaning of the notification.
  • Notification No. 16/2025–Central Tax (Rate) read with amendments to Notification No. 12/2017.
  • Clause 36D – exemption applicable where the insured is not a group.
  • IRDAI (Health Insurance) Regulations, 2016 and Insurance Products Regulations, 2024.
  • Judicial precedents on interpretation of fiscal exemptions vs charging provisions.

Observations

Clear legislative intent – individual focus:

  • The exemption, as per GST Council recommendations and Notification, is explicitly designed for individual health insurance policies, including family floater policies.
  • The explanatory clause removes ambiguity by clarifying that exemption applies only to individuals and their families.

Group policies – commercially and structurally distinct:

  • The Court noted that the subject policies:
    • Were negotiated collectively by IBA,
    • Covered a significantly large and identifiable class of persons, and
    • Offered benefits such as lower premiums, relaxed underwriting, coverage of pre-existing diseases, and administrative efficiencies.
  • These features inherently distinguish group policies from retail individual insurance products.

Interpretation of “group” – rejection of artificial distinction:

  • Petitioners relied on the phrase “other than availing insurance” in the definition of “group”.

  • Under IRDAI regulations, no group can be constituted solely for the purpose of availing insurance, and

  • Existence of a valid policy itself evidences a pre-existing relationship and regulatory compliance, thereby confirming group character.

Interest on Refund of Unconstitutional Levy Payable from Date of Deposit — Section 56 Not Restrictive

Paradeep Phosphates Limited v. Additional Commissioner GST (Appeals) [2026] W.P.(C) No. 11618 of 2024 (Orissa High Court)

Issue

  • Whether interest on refund of IGST paid on ocean freight (CIF imports) is payable from the date of deposit, when such levy is subsequently declared unconstitutional.
  • Whether Section 56 of the CGST Act restricts interest only to cases of delay beyond 60 days from refund application.

Facts

  • The petitioner imported goods on CIF basis and paid IGST on ocean freight under reverse charge, in terms of Notifications No. 8/2017 and 10/2017.
  • Such payment was made under protest, while simultaneously challenging the levy before the High Court.
  • The levy was ultimately declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in Mohit Minerals.
  • Pursuant to this:
    • Refund of IGST was granted by the department,
    • However, interest was denied on the ground that refund was processed within 60 days under Section 56.
  • The petitioner challenged denial of interest before the High Court.
  • Article 265 of the Constitution tax cannot be levied/collected without authority of law.
  • Section 54 and Section 56 of the CGST Act.
  • Notifications No. 8/2017 & 10/2017 (declared ultra vires).
  • Supreme Court ruling in Union of India v. Mohit Minerals Pvt. Ltd.
  • Doctrine of restitution and unjust enrichment jurisprudence.

Observations

Nature of refund not a statutory refund:

  • The Court distinguished between:
    • Refund arising from statutory proceedings, and

    • Refund arising due to unconstitutional levy.

  • In the present case, refund was not a routine statutory refund but flowed from a void levy.

Section 56 not exhaustive:

  • Section 56 governs interest on delayed refunds, i.e., where refund is otherwise validly due under the statute.
  • It is silent on cases where tax itself is held to be illegal or unconstitutional.

Illegal levy cannot be retained:

  • Once the levy is declared unconstitutional:
    • The State has no authority to retain the amount, and
    • Retention amounts to unjust enrichment at the cost of the taxpayer.

Doctrine of restitution applies:

  • The Court held that refund must restore the taxpayer to the original position.
  • Mere refund of principal without interest would be incomplete restitution, as the State had use of the money.

Interest as compensation (not penalty):

  • Interest represents compensation for deprivation of money, not a statutory penalty.
  • Therefore, entitlement arises independent of Section 56, based on equitable and constitutional principles.

Starting point of interest:

  • Since the tax itself was wrongfully collected, interest must run from the date of deposit, not from the refund application date.

Outcome / Held

  • The petitioner is entitled to interest @6% p.a. on the refunded IGST amount.
  • Interest shall be computed from the date of deposit of tax till the date of actual refund.
  • Denial of interest by authorities based on Section 56 was held to be legally unsustainable.

February 2026

No IGST on Salary Paid to Expat Employees — Employer–Employee Relationship Excluded from ‘Supply’

Huawei Technologies India Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Karnataka & Ors. [2025] W.P. No. 2848 of 2024 (Karnataka High Court)

Issue

Whether salary paid by an Indian company to expatriate employees constitutes:

  • “Import of manpower services” liable to IGST under RCM, or
  • A non-taxable employer–employee transaction under Schedule III of the CGST Act.

Facts

  • The petitioner employed foreign nationals under direct employment contracts in India.
  • Such employees:
    • Were on the payroll of the Indian entity,
    • Received salary, bonus, allowances, etc., and
    • Paid income tax in India like domestic employees.
  • The department issued an SCN alleging:
    • Import of “Manpower Recruitment and Supply Services” from foreign entities,
    • Liability to pay IGST under Reverse Charge Mechanism.
  • Demand raised: INR 85 crore (plus interest and penalty).
  • Entry 1 of Schedule III of the CGST Act – services by employee to employer not treated as supply.
  • Section 2(77) – definition of “non-resident taxable person”.
  • Section 2(11) of IGST Act – import of services.
  • CBIC Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST (valuation in related party transactions).

Observations

Existence of genuine employer–employee relationship:

  • The Court relied on:
    • Employment contracts,
    • Payroll structure,
    • TDS deductions,
    • Working conditions and benefits.
  • It concluded that expats were employees of the Indian entity, not secondees or service providers.

Schedule III exclusion applies:

  • Services rendered by employees in course of employment are neither supply of goods nor services.

  • Therefore, salary payments fall outside GST ambit entirely.

Not a case of import of services:

  • For “import”, supplier must be located outside India and supply must exist.
  • In this case:

i. Employees were working in India, ii. No independent “service” existed, iii. Hence, import conditions not satisfied.

Expats not ‘non-resident taxable persons:

  • They were:

i. Residing in India, ii. Not making “occasional supplies”, iii. Not acting as independent suppliers.

  • Therefore, classification under Section 2(77) was rejected.

Alternate argument – even if supply assumed:

  • As per CBIC Circular:

i. Where no invoice is raised and full ITC available, ii. Open market value deemed to be Nil.

  • Hence, even on a without prejudice basis, no tax liability arises.

Rejection of “manpower supply” characterization:

  • The arrangement was not secondment or outsourcing.

  • It was a direct employment structure, eliminating GST exposure.

Outcome / Held

  • Salary paid to expatriate employees is not liable to IGST.
  • Transaction qualifies as employer–employee relationship under Schedule III.
  • SCN demanding INR 85 crore IGST was quashed in entirety.

Non-Compete Fee Qualifies as ‘Export of Service’ to Overseas Entity – Partly Taxable for Domestic Portion

Jolarpettai Veeramuthu Sreedhar [2026] Advance Ruling No. 2/ARA/2026 (Tamil Nadu AAR, Ruling)

Issue

  • Whether non-compete consideration received pursuant to sale of shares qualifies as:

a) A “supply of service” under GST, and b) “Export of service” (zero-rated) when rendered to a foreign entity.

  • Whether the same transaction can be partly export and partly domestic supply, requiring apportionment.

Facts

  • The applicant sold shares in a company and entered into a non-compete agreement with:

a) One US-based entity, and b) One Indian entity.

  • Consideration received: USD 2,67,321.60 as non-compete fee.
  • The agreement required the applicant to: refrain from engaging in competing business activities.
  • The applicant sought advance ruling on:

a) Taxability, b) Export qualification, and c) GST liability on such consideration.

  • Schedule II, Clause 5(e), CGST Act – agreeing to refrain from an act = supply of service.
  • Section 9(1), CGST Act – levy of GST on supply.
  • Section 2(6), IGST Act – definition of “export of service”.
  • Sections 12 & 13, IGST Act – place of supply provisions.

Observations

  • Non-compete is treated supply of service:

  • The AAR held that agreeing not to compete falls squarely within:

  • “Agreeing to refrain from an act”,

  • Hence, qualifies as taxable supply of service.

  • Export conditions satisfied (for US entity):

For the portion attributable to the US- based entity:

a) Recipient located outside India, b) Place of supply outside India, c) Consideration received in convertible foreign exchange, d) Parties not merely establishments of same entity.

  • Hence, qualifies as export of service under Section 2(6).

Place of supply determination (functional approach):

  • Though not independently ruled upon, AAR examined place of supply to determine taxability.

Held that:

  • Services relating to foreign entity – outside India,
  • Services relating to Indian entity – within India.

Apportionment of consideration:

  • The total non-compete fee was split as:

    • 98.57% - Export (US entity)
    • 1.43% - Domestic supply (Indian entity)
  • This reflects substance-over-form approach in mixed recipient transactions.

  • Dual tax treatment upheld:

  • A single agreement can give rise to:

    • Zero-rated export supply, and
    • Taxable domestic supply simultaneously.

Outcome / Held

  • Non-compete agreement constitutes a supply of service.
  • Portion attributable to US entity qualifies as export of service (zero-rated, Nil GST).
  • Portion attributable to Indian entity is taxable under GST (as applicable).

March 2026

ISD Credit to be Distributed Only Upon Eligibility Under Section 16 — Rule 39(1)(a) Upheld

Reliance Jio Infocomm Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. [2026] W.P. Nos. 27038 & 28371 of 2025 (Madras High Court)

Issue

  • Whether Rule 39(1)(a) mandating distribution of ITC by ISD in the same month as the invoice is:
    • Ultra vires Section 20 of the CGST Act, and
    • Arbitrary / impractical in light of Section 16 conditions.
  • Whether ITC can be distributed prior to fulfillment of eligibility conditions under Section 16(2).

Facts

  • The petitioner, a telecom company with multiple GST registrations, operated through an Input Service Distributor (ISD) mechanism.
  • Department issued SCNs alleging:
    • ITC was not distributed in the same month as receipt of invoices,
    • Resulting in contravention of Rule 39(1)(a).
  • Petitioner challenged:
    • Constitutional validity of Rule 39(1)(a), and
    • SCNs for multiple years (FY 2018–19 to 2023–24).
  • ITC distribution cannot precede verification of eligibility under Section 16(2).

Observations

  • Harmonious interpretation of Sections 16 & 20, the Court held that ITC distribution cannot be viewed in isolation.

  • The phrase “credit available for distribution” must mean credit that has become legally available under Section 16(2).

  • Eligibility precedes distribution: ITC becomes “available” only upon fulfillment of conditions such as: Possession of invoice, Receipt of goods/services, Tax payment by supplier and Filing of returns.

  • Therefore, distribution is triggered only after eligibility crystallizes.

  • Revenue argued that distribution must be linked solely to invoice date and the court rejected this, holding that: Distribution of “invoice” does not equate to distribution of “credit”,

  • Credit must exist in law before it can be distributed and it was interpreted in line with Section 16, i.e. same-month distribution applies only when ITC is legally available.

  • Literal interpretation (distribution based only on invoice) would force distribution of ineligible credit and lead to reversals, interest, and litigation.

  • Court held such interpretation as legally unsustainable and reiterated settled principle that ITC is a statutory concession and available only upon strict compliance with conditions.

Outcome / Held

  • Rule 39(1)(a) is valid and intra vires.
  • However, it must be interpreted to mean:
    • ITC shall be distributed in the month in which it becomes available under Section 16(2).
  • Distribution cannot precede eligibility; hence, invoice date alone is not determinative.

Solique Advisors

[email protected]

India | UAE | USA | Canada

Keep a copy for reference

Download the original Solique Advisors publication.

PDF · 20 pages · 2.3 MB
Back to all publications