International Tax & Transfer Pricing Updates — Q4 FY 2023–24

This Q4 FY 2023-24 newsletter reviews international tax and transfer pricing developments. It includes the OECD's global minimum tax analysis and selected transfer pricing issues and rulings.

By Solique Advisors7 min readnewsletter

PDF · 3 pages · 0.4 MB

Original PDF cover for International Tax & Transfer Pricing Updates — Q4 FY 2023–24
The original Solique Advisors publication
In this publication

January 2024 — Q4 of FY 2023-24

International Tax Updates

OECD has released a working paper titled “The Global Minimum Tax and the taxation of MNE profit” presenting the economic impact of the Global Minimum Tax's (GMT) based on new data on Multinational Enterprises (MNE).

  • GMT significantly diminishes incentives for profit shifting.

  • GMT is projected to substantially decrease globally low-taxed profit by curtailing profit shifting and implementing top-up taxation.

  • GMT is expected to boost Corporate Income-tax revenues.

  • GMT is anticipated to reduce tax rate differentials among jurisdictions, potentially impacting investment allocation and MNE activity.

Australia – ATO released PCG 2024/1 for intangible arrangements involving international related parties, focusing on economic substance over legal form. Risks are grouped into migration of intangible assets and mischaracterization /nonrecognition of Australian activities. Further, a risk rating system has been introduced to prioritize enforcement.

Spain – The Ministry of Finance has announced a draft legislation for comments aiming to incorporate the Pillar Two effective tax rate of 15% for MNEs and large domestic groups into Spanish domestic law. Aligned with the EU Minimum Tax Directive and OECD Model Rules, the legislation introduces an Income Inclusion Rule and an Undertaxed Profits Rule. The public consultation period ended on January 19, 2024.

International Tax Rulings

‘Make Available’ clause is not satisfied to be taxed as FTS in case of payment to non-resident entities for repair and maintenance of helicopter parts. It is necessary to demonstrate that technical knowledge has been effectively transferred to meet the make available criteria. – M/s. Global Vectra Helicorp Ltd. Vs. DCIT[2024] ITA Nos 1397, 1482 TO 1487 /Delhi/2020(Delhi ITAT)

Transfer Pricing Updates

Indonesia – Ministry of Finance has issued updated Transfer Pricing (‘TP’) guidelines through Regulation No. 172 of 2023 (PKM-172), effective from December 29, 2023. This guidelines consolidates various TP principles that were previously covered under separate regulations on TP documentation requirements, application of the ALP, transfer pricing adjustments, MAP, and APA.

Transfer Pricing Rulings

TP provisions do not apply to the extent of operation carried on by a company through qualifying ships which is covered by Tonnage Tax Scheme. – M/s. Essar Shipping Limited vs. ACIT [2024] ITA No 2951/Mum/2022 (Mumbai ITAT)

The nature of a loan, whether it is considered quasi-capital or not, has to be assessed at the time of advancement of loan to the Associated enterprise. The conversion of such loan into equity at a later date does not alter its nature at the time of advancement.– M/s. Intas Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Vs. ACIT [2024] ITA No. 1334 /AHD)/ 2017(ITAT Ahmedabad)

February 2024 — Q4 of FY 2023-24

International Tax Updates

OECD has released the final report on Pillar One - Amount B which provides for streamlined approach for applying the arm's-length principle to in-country baseline marketing and distribution activities.

Australia - ATO has issued an updated Draft Taxation Ruling 2024/D1, regarding withholding tax on software royalties, which is open for public consultation. The draft maintains the perspective that the utilization or granting of rights to intellectual property will result in a Royalty.

Mexico - The Mexican Tax Authority (SAT) has announced its Master Plan for the year 2024, which emphasizes taxpayer assistance, revenue collection, and auditing. The plan leverages AI to develop analytical models to identify tax evasion schemes and classify high-risk taxpayers.

International Tax Rulings

Taxpayer's eligibility for exemption under Article 24 of the India-UAE DTAA cannot be denied over a minor detail, such as the mobile number being mentioned as "9999999999" in the return of income. The Court took a prudent stance, emphasizing that such an approach is "to be frowned upon and is liable to be rejected at the threshold”. – M/s. ADIA v. DCIT [2024] ITA No.3415/Mum/2023 (ITAT Mumbai)

German Federal Tax Court (BFH) ruled that a UK-based aircraft engineer’s use of a personal locker at a German airport constituted a permanent establishment (PE) for tax purpose and the income earned from the maintenance of aircraft in Germany was held liable to tax. Locker used to store work-related items provided a sufficient business presence under German tax law and the German-UK tax treaty. ECLI:DE:BFH:2023:U.070623.IR47.20.0 (German Federal Tax Court)

Transfer Pricing Updates

Switzerland - Federal Tax Authorities released comprehensive guidance in a Q&A format on the practical application of transfer pricing rules. This guidance aligns with the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines and provides clarification on methodologies, comparability analysis, and financial transaction treatments to ensure adherence to the arm's-length principle for fair taxation of cross-border intra-group transactions.

Transfer Pricing Rulings

Expenditure incurred for Share-based compensation (ESOP) shall be treated as “Non-operating” in nature for computation of the Operating profit Margins (Profit Level Indicator). – M/s. Amazon Seller Services (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2024] IT(TP)A No. 418/Bang/ 2023 (ITAT Bangalore)

Safe Harbour Rules are specifically enacted for Eligible Transactions listed in Rule 10TC of the IT rules 1962. Transaction of outstanding receivables/interest thereon are different from the eligible list of International transactions prescribed. As a result, Assessee cannot claim that benefit of ALP adjustment on Outstanding receivables is already subsumed in the mark up of 25% offered under Safe Harbour Rules – M/s. Iomedia India Pvt. Ltd v. ACIT [2024] ITA No. 995/Del/2021 (HC Delhi)

March 2024 — Q4 of FY 2023-24

International Tax Updates

Germany - The Growth Opportunities Act was revised to introduce key amends such as interest deduction limitation on intercompany financing, revision in claw-back provisions to tax-neutral demergers and updated “Check-the-box” elections for partnerships.

United Kingdom - Spring Budget 2024 has brought in key amendments including reduced National Insurance Contributions (NIC) contributions, new tax reliefs for Creative Industries, and introduction of Reserved Investor Fund (tax-efficient investment fund vehicle for institutional investors).

Italy – The Ministry of Economy and Finance has released a decree for implementation of the Investment Management Exemption (IME). IME is a legal framework that ensures certainty for non-resident funds and investors and avoid triggering an Italian PE.

United States - Stop Subsidizing Giant Mergers Act – Bill has been unveiled, aimed at eliminating tax-free mergers and taxpayer subsidies for acquisitions that consolidate corporate power. The Bill affects the corporate mergers and acquisitions involving firms with combined average annual gross receipts exceeding $500 million over the prior three years, with exceptions for small businesses and internal reorganizations.

International Tax Rulings

KPMG, tax advisors was held to be guilty of professional misconduct for failing in its duty to advise a client adequately. Despite recommending a tax plan, Court held that KPMG neglected to analyze the risks specific to the client and the potential application of GAAR. As a result of substantial tax liabilities due to the flawed advice, damages was awarded against KPMG – Pilon et. Al [500-17-115092-200] (Quebec Superior Court)

Where an Italy-resident taxpayer earns income in UAE, treaty benefits under the Italy-UAE DTAA can be availed even though there is no taxation of such income in UAE – Alessandro Fiaschi [Civile Ord. Sez. 5 Num. 8580 Anno 2023] (Italy Supreme Court)

The District court of Netherlands held that interest received on net equity (‘IoNE’) from shares held by the Assessee qualifies as dividend and accordingly, the taxpayer was entitled to a tax saving credit of 25% as per Article 23(4)(a) of the Netherlands-Brazil DTAA. The court further ruled that any ambiguity in the treaty text should not be construed to the detriment of the taxpayer – ECLI:NL:RBZWB:2023:2936 (District Court of Netherlands)

Transfer Pricing Rulings

Letter of Comfort from the holding company to the subsidiary company for credit facilities does not constitute a guarantee. TPO’s adjustment towards guarantee commission shall be deleted –M/s. Lupin Ltd. Vs. DCIT [2024] ITA No. 77/Mum/2021(Mumbai ITAT)

Where the computation of income based on the ALP adjustment results in reduction in the income or an increase in their loss, such computation of income based on the ALP does not apply. TP provisions shall not be enforced if such adjustment would diminish the Indian tax base – PCIT v. M/s. Mercer Consulting India (P.) Ltd. [2024] ITA No. 217/2017 (High Court of Delhi)

Segmental accounts cannot be rejected solely on the basis that they have not been audited, unless a specific fallacy or defect is identified – M/s. Spectris Technologies (P.) Ltd. v. DCIT [2024] ITA No. 1818 (DELHI) OF 2013 (Delhi ITAT)

Capital Gains on transfer of shares prior to April 1, 2017, are not taxable as per India-Mauritius DTAA. Further, held that CBDT upheld the sanctity of TRC vide Circular no. 789/2000 and TRC issued by Mauritius Tax authority cannot be questioned. – M/s. Norwest Ventures Partners X – Mauritus vs. DCIT [2024] ITA No. 2311/Del/2023 (Delhi ITAT).

Disclaimer

The information contained in this document prepared by Solique Advisory And Support Services Private Limited, Chennai (‘Solique'), is furnished to the recipient, for information purposes only. Solique will not be liable for any loss or damage caused by the reader’s reliance on information obtained through this report. Solique do not assume any responsibility or liability for any loss or damage, resulting from use of this report or from any content for communications or materials available on this report. The contents are provided for your reference only.

Keep a copy for reference

Download the original Solique Advisors publication.

PDF · 3 pages · 0.4 MB
Back to all publications